Hunting Matthew Nichols

On October 31, 2001, teenager Matthew Nichols and his best friend, Jordan Reimer, disappeared in the woods of Vancouver Island. In 2023, Matthew's younger sister, Tara, begins working on a documentary film with director Markian Tarasiuk in an attempt to come to a resolution regarding the unsolved disappearances. Tara, Markian, and his cinematographer Ryan McDonald, return to Vancouver Island and interview her mother, alongside several other individuals, including Pam Hamilton, a lead investigator on Matthew and Jordan's case. During interviews, Pam expresses the belief that Matthew and Jordan became lost in the woods and fell into a ravine or river, and both died. The only evidence discovered in the case was a camcorder belonging to Matthew which was found in an abandoned cabin that was alleged to have been built by a local religious leader from decades before, who led a small commune in the woods. After poring through evidence released to the Nichols family by the local police department, Tara deduces that one of the mini DV tapes admitted into to the police file is missing. A month later, Tara is able to obtain it from the authorities. Upon watching the tape, Tara, Markian, and Ryan find it to contain disturbing footage of Matthew and Jordan engaging in what appears to be a Satanic occult ritual, which culminates in Matthew violently murdering Jordan by strangling him and gouging out his eyes with his fingers. After viewing the tape, a distraught Tara walks into the ocean and nearly drowns herself, resulting in Markian suggesting they abort their documentary. Tara and Markian visit Jordan's father, who reluctantly gives them an antique grimoire Matthew and Jordan stole from the local library. Next, Tara confronts Pam, accusing her of concealing the existence of the tape as well as an animal skull totem which was also found at the cabin. Pam claims the police department chose to keep the tape from the public to avoid a mass hysteria, believing it to be an amateur short horror film Matthew and Jordan shot, inspired by The Blair Witch Project. Despite Pam's claim that authorities razed the cabin, Tara insists on exploring the area, with Markian reluctantly agreeing to accompany her. While camping in the woods, Tara awakens Markian in the middle of the night, bringing him to the cabin, which she discovered is inexplicably adjacent to their campsite. Using a necklace gifted to her by Matthew as a pendulum, along with the skull totem, Tara seems to communicate with an entity claiming to be Matthew. Moments later, she is forcefully dragged outside by an unseen force. Markian flees after Tara, finding her distraught and stating that the being she was communicating with is in fact not Matthew. The two are attacked by unseen entities, before Markian finds a nude Tara standing at the base of a tree, where multiple nude human figures are fixed above. The figures descend the tree and attack Markian. In a mid-credits sequence, a disfigured Markian is visited in the hospital by Ryan. When Ryan approaches him, Markian begins screaming and violently convulsing.